HIV Health Services Planning Council
City Hall, Mayor’s Conference Room (Rm. 201)
1 Dr. Carlton B. Goodlett Place
November 22, 2004
4:30 PM - 7:30 PM
DRAFT MINUTES

I. Call to Order

II. Roll Call

III. Review and Approval of Agenda
CM Booker announced that Jeff Sheehy may not be able to attend the meeting for his agenda item.
The agenda was reviewed and approved.

IV. Review and Approval of Minutes- October 25, 2004
CM Byers requested that his absence (A) in the roll call be changed to excused (E).
With these changes the minutes were approved.

V. General Announcements
• Bylaws Change Vote Notification
Vote to occur at the January 24, 2005 HIV Health Services Planning Council meeting.
The HIV Health Services Planning Council is required to provide 30 days notice of a vote that results in changes to the Council's written Bylaws. The changes to the Bylaws the Planning Council will consider may be viewed on the following attachment of the Council's Bylaws. The Council intends to discuss and vote on the changes at the January 24, 2005 HIV Health Services Planning Council meeting.
CM Booker noticed the bylaws change to be voted on at the January Council meeting.
CM Allgaier announced that Jack Newby’s mother had passed away and he will be out of the office until after Thanksgiving.
CM Allgaier stated that the evaluation of the prioritization process was due on December 22nd and encouraged Council members to fill one out.
CM Sanders announced that he will be moving to Palm Beach County Florida and this will be his last meeting.
CM Tanner stated that he had gone to speak at Bayview Hunter’s Point Community Center about HIV/AIDS safe sex, and stated that education outreach efforts are needed in that area.


VI. Public Comment
Sally Liska, Director of the DPH Lab, thanked the Council for directing funding for HIV viral load testing (therapeutic monitoring), which had also helped in restoring state funding for testing.
Patrick Monette Shaw stated that the Council should not ignore Jeff Sheehy’s failure to attend the Council’s prioritization meetings.
Bill Hirsch from the ALRP announced that the Board of Supervisors will hold a hearing on December 2nd at 10am and encouraged people to attend.
CM Geanuracos stated that the UCSF project, Connect to Protect, was starting on a 6-year process of looking at influences/risk factors of HIV. (goal to mobilize community, had first meeting of community providers, 12 agencies from east bay and sf)

VII. Introduction of HIV/AIDS Policy Advisor to the Mayor
Jeff Sheehy, HIV/AIDS Policy Advisor to the Mayor
Mr. Sheehy did not attend this meeting.

Public Comment on this item
There was no public comment on this item.

VIII. Robert’s Rules of Order Training
Travis Barrick, JD, MPA, PRP
Prioritization Activity
Travis Barrick presented a basic training session for Council members in parliamentary procedure on motions, amendments, voting, debate, etc.

Public Comment on this item
There was no public comment on this item.


IX. Prevention with Positives Committee Presentation
Representatives from the HIV Prevention Planning Council, Prevention with Positives Committee presented “A New Slice of Prevention,” a presentation of guiding principles for Prevention With Positives programs in San Francisco.

Public Comment on this item
There was no public comment on this item.

X. Dinner Break

XI. Unobligated Funds- VOTE
Infrastructure & Policy Committee, Charles Siron

The Council discussed the following motions from Steering regarding the unobligated funds:

Motion 1: If unobligated funds become available, $238K will go for vouchers to be distributed only to CARE-funded agencies.

CM Pearce asked for the reasoning behind these motions.
CM Allgaier responded that the amounts were still unknown and the funds needed to be spent quickly, by February 28, 2005. The vouchers would also be useful later on for COE’s.
CM Thomas added that the motions were phrased as “first” amounts of money, because the amounts are unknown, which makes it difficult to put back into services.
CM Tanner spoke in favor of the motions.

Public Comment on this item:
Patrick Monette Shaw expressed concern that the council is voting on unobligated funds without knowing the dollar amount.
Bill Hirsch encouraged the Council to help with the continuity of services.
Raymond Banks stated that vouchers were useful for people in need to help adhere to treatment.

• Roll call vote on motion 1. See Attachment A, Column 2. The motion passed.

Motion 2: Any remaining money will go to Direct Emergency Financial Assistance.
CM Pearce stated that by voting on directives to the AIDS Office without knowing amounts, the Council could be liable if there was a lot of unobligated leftover.
Russ Zellers stated that the money comes from funds pulled back from contracts, but it is unknown because the AIDS Office sometimes gets billed at the end of the fiscal year. They do not expect it to be a large amount.
CM Allgaier noted that the second motion came out of Steering and the vouchers had been voted for over money for therapeutic monitoring.
CM Byers spoke in favor of the motion, stating that this was part of an annual process and that the AIDS Office is not responsible for the timeliness of billing from providers.
CM Pugh asked if information was available from Reggie.
Russ Zellers responded that fiscal expenditures cannot be projected from units of services. Invoices are more accurate. Providers also have the opportunity to request to re-allocate those dollars.
CM Pugh encouraged the Council to look at other contractors who might need funds.
CM Tanner stated that emergency funds help consumers.
CM Antonetty reminded the Council that emergency funds are used to pay directly needs such as rent, food, and bills to help clients.
CM Byers stated that San Francisco’s process for distributing these funds was less political, and cited the process in other jurisdictions, where the AIDS Office weighs arguments for which service category presents the most compelling case to get the funds.

Public comment on this item:
Patrick Monette Shaw stated that services could be saved and recommended that the Council implement a mid-year review process.

• Roll Call Vote. See Attachment A, Column 3. The motion passed.

XII. CARE Act Reauthorization Update/ Discussion
Laura Thomas and Lara Sallee
CM Thomas & CM Sallee presented an update on the CARE Act reauthorization and discussed current concerns.

Public Comment on this item

XIII. CAEAR Coalition -VOTE
Council Co-Chairs
The Council voted in favor of accepting the SF AIDS Foundation as a sponsor for the Council’s CAEAR Coalition memberships.
The Council voted in favor of having the 3 Council Co-chairs (rotating) and the Director of Council Support as representatives from the Planning Council on the CAEAR Council.

Public Comment on this item
There was no public comment on this item.

XIV. HOPWA Loan Committee Seat -VOTE
Community Outreach & Advocacy Committee
The Council voted in favor of appointing Council Member Wilfredo Ortiz to the Council’s second HOPWA (Housing Opportunities for People Living with AIDS) Loan Committee seat.

Public Comment on this item
There was no public comment on this item.

XV. Close Nominations for Prevention with Positives Representatives- VOTE
Council Co-chairs
The Council voted to appoint Council Members William Blum, Ken Pearce, and Joe McMurray as official Council representatives on the Prevention with Positives Committee.
The members nominated will report to back to the Council at the Community Outreach & Advocacy Committee meetings.

CM McMurray spoke for CM when he stated that it was a lot to ask Prevention With Positive Committee members to attend and report to the Community Outreach committee, especially since it did not count towards membership attendance.
CM McMurray will report to the Community Outreach committee, as he is co-chair of that committee.

XVI. Thank You to Council Members
Jack Newby, Director of Council Support
CM Allgaier presented Council Members with certificates of appreciation for volunteering to serve on the Council.

Public Comment on this item
There was no public comment on this item

XVII. New Business/ Next Agenda

XVIII. Adjourned 7:30.

Meeting minutes are considered to be in DRAFT form until reviewed and approved by Council attendees.

Home | Community Outreach & Advocacy Committee | Policy & Evaluation Committee | Evaluation Committee
Membership Committee | Planning Committee | Steering Committee